Monday, July 30, 2018

A TALE OF TWO PROGRAM HOSTS • SPRING DIARY RATINGS FOR BURLINGTON, PORTLAND & ROCHESTER


Alison Stewart

Alison Stewart and Leonard LoPate have at least one thing in common: Both have fond feelings about the weekday Noon – 2:00pm shift on WNYC-FM in New York.

Lopate was host of The Leonard Lopate Show on WNYC for many years before he was suspended and eventually fired in December 2017 amid allegations of “inappropriate conduct.” 

He had worked at the station for over 30 years.

Stewart, a media jack-of-all-trades, will begin hosting WNYC’s Noon – 2pm program (LoPate's old shift) this fall. 


She wants her new show to be a hit public radio program, in part, because her previous effort for NPR, The Bryant Park Project, ended with a whimper after less than a year in national syndication. Bryant Park was a critical success but it failed to catch on with NPR-member stations.

LoPate and Stewart are at different points in their careers. LoPate recently resurfaced on New York radio at WBAI-FM [link].  Stewart [link] has been doing part-time reporting for PBS. A couple of years ago she authored the highly acclaimed book First Class: The Legacy of Dunbar, America’s First Black Public High School.

Stewart seems like a perfect match for WNYC. In addition to her writing and work on Bryant Park, she is a veteran of MTV News, MSNBC, ABC and CBS. She hopes her new program, in LoPate’s old airtime, will be the hit she wants and deserves.

LOPATE: WORKING AT WBAI HAS BEEN “QUITE DISTURBING”

Leonard LoPate
Since leaving WNYC, the road has been tough for Lopate. To his credit, he has kept working hard while trying to regain credibility in a fickle business.

LoPate joined a small, NPR-affiliate, WHDD, an hour north of the city. His one-hour show was also marketed as a podcast. The WHDD gig was likely a big drop in salary. In 2015 we published a report that LoPate was paid over $250,000 a year by WNYC.

Then, in July LoPate accepted an offer from beleaguered Pacifica station WBAI for a weekday one-hour show. Many observers wonder if LoPate made the right move by joining WBAI, a station with many problems and questionable reputation.

According to a recent article in Columbia Journalism Review (CJR) [link], after being hired by WBAI’s General Manager Berthold Reimers, LoPate is realizing that he may be worse off at WBAI than he was at WNYC.

Keep in mind that WBAI does not have the infrastructure of WNYC. When Reimers hired LoPate, he told CJR “You know at WBAI, I don’t think we have 5,000 people listening for the whole week.”  WNYC had almost a million weekly listeners in the June 2018 Nielsen Audio ratings.

Other sources report that LoPate’s show on WBAI has been marred by technical and timing snafus. Reportedly, he has had trouble booking guests because of the persistent “stink” of his departure from WNYC. Also, WBAI has only one working phone line which makes it difficult to do a talk show.

It is also hard to say whether LoPate has helped WBAI. A couple of weeks after LoPate’s show began, WBAI lost one of its very few bankable personalities, DJ Jay Smooth, who quit rather than be on the same station as LoPate.

Lopate’s producer, Mimi Rosenberg, told CJR that his time at WBAI so far has been “quite disturbing.”

Maybe things will eventually turn around for LoPate.  He is a very talented fellow, who, with the proper technical support, is capable of doing excellent radio work again.  We do wish him well.

But, for now, Misery Loves Company and LoPate and WBAI are apparently miserable together.

NEW METRIC ADDED FOR NIELSEN AUDIO RATINGS REPORTING

A number of Spark News readers have asked us to publish more detailed data from Nielsen Audio’s ratings. We have been providing estimated weekly listeners (“cume”) – a powerful metric.  Now we are adding Average-Quarter-Hour (AQH) listeners to station reports.

AQH is also a powerful metric because it combines cume and time spent listening to provide an estimate of the number of people listening during an average quarter hour.  Please let us know if you think we are adding information that is of value to you. You can direct comments directly to us at publicradio@hotmail.com.



The first of our Spring 2018 reports from markets where Nielsen uses Diary methodology is for Burlington-Plattsburgh.   

As you can see in chart on the left, Vermont Public Radio’s (VPR) News stations have an increase in the number of estimated weekly listeners but fwere AQH listeners.  How can this be?

The answer is, more people are tuning in to VPR News but overall people are spending less time listening. 

This is a trend that is being watched for radio listening in general. Retaining listeners in a major challenge for stations in our multi-channel, multiple platform media world.

Also note that AQH measures listening only in the core metro area and estimated weekly listeners measure listening in a the total survey area (“TSA”) which includes listeners outside of the metro area. You can  this in the Burlington-Plattsburgh report where New Hampshire Public Radio (NHPR) has 26,100 estimate weekly listeners but there are no AQH listeners in the metro area.





The big news from Portland, Maine is the growth of Maine Public’s Classical music programming channel. 

Maine Public recently added a new powerful signal, WBQA a/k/a K-Bach, to the Classical network and it is really paying off.

The difference between cume and AQH is also a factor in the Portland market.   

Note that NHPR has an estimated 33,100 weekly listeners in the total survey area but it isn’t even a factor in the Portland metro.


In Rochester, New York, NPR News/Talk station WXXI-AM has a stronger presence compared to Spring 2017. 

They are up in both weekly listeners and metro AQH listeners.  These are trends station programmers like to see.

WXXI-AM also benefits from simulcasts of NPR News magazines on WRUR during drive times.   

WEOS in exurban Geneva has lots of listeners in the  total survey area but only a handful in the Rochester metro.


No comments:

Post a Comment