Friday, January 4, 2019


Air1, a national noncommercial Christian channel owned by the Educational Media Foundation (EMF), pulled the plug on Christian Contemporary Music (CCM) on January 1st and replaced it with Worship Music

Though most people involved with media aren’t familiar with this type of music, within the Christian music and radio biz EMF’s change is big and somewhat controversial decision.

Before the change, Air1 played what it called Positive Hits – a blend of current-based pop and rock music. 

Since the change, Air1’s positioning slogan has become Worship Wherever You Are, reflecting music meant specifically for a personal worship experience. You can listen to Air1’s streaming audio here.

The change is a big move for EMF, the nation’s largest noncommercial Christian radio broadcaster. In the 2017 tax year, EMF reported revenue of over $213 million. EMF feeds, via satellite, three 24/7 automated music channels to approximately 700 FM stations and translators. All three channels feature variations of contemporary Christian music.

Worship Music, also called Praise Music, is criticized because it brings the listener into a virtual church experience without the hassle of actually attending a church on the corner. Rather than stogy hymns, Worship Music has a contemporary sound and style. It is similar to what is heard at Evangelical mega churches.

Some people strongly object to Worship Music on the radio because they feel it is not respectful of traditional church decorum. Some Christian musicians dislike Worship Music on the radio because it is an oldies-based format that plays very few artists. There is also concern that Worship Music is cookie-cutter formula designed to please yuppies. One blogger described it this way:

Worship music is to music what Old Navy is to clothing. It is wholesome and American-ish, even when it is made by Australians. [It is] written and performed by attractive young people sporting angular haircuts, tight T-shirts, and tattoos.


Mark Ramsey
Mark Ramsey, the well-known secular media researcher, consultant, blogger and podcaster announced the opening FaithBright [link], a division of his media work. 

Ramsey told us by email:

 SPARK NEWS: Is EMF changing Air1 because its music footprint was too similar to K-Love? 

RAMSEY:  I work with K-LOVE (although not with AIR1) so I am not at liberty to comment on this. Sorry!

SPARK NEWS:  Some in the CCM music biz are saying the change is a retreat from Contemporary Christian music. Is there concern that CCM is loosing its impact?

RAMSEY: I think what EMF does with AIR1 has everything to do with the role AIR1 plays in their portfolio relative to K-LOVE. And that’s a problem that only EMF has. No other broadcaster has it. So, in other words, I don’t think there’s a larger lesson there.

As a format Christian AC (which is how I like to refer to the format) is growing. And every time EMF puts another K-LOVE on the air it grows again.

Mark Ramsey Promotional Image
The real issue is how to appeal to younger people with some form of Christian music that is liked enough by enough people to fit in one format on one station and generate significant listening.

It should not surprise us that this is difficult. In the secular world. The the only formats that pull this off are CHR and Urban. New Rock is all but non-existent.

SPARK NEWS:  Talk a bit about why this programming means so much to you.

RAMSEY:  Many of my clients are in this space. The goal is to actually improve the lives of listeners through on-air storytelling and encouragement. That’s a high mission, and I’m thrilled to be part of it.

To be clear, I continue to be open for business in all formats including public radio. But the Christian clients require some special strategies and so I have opened a new division to serve them specifically. Thanks Ken!

According to Ramsey, FaithBright provides custom strategic research, perceptual studies and best practices. In a press release announcing FaithBright, Ramsey said the initiative will be announcing a new proprietary system to magnify the effectiveness of station fundraising efforts and appeals to major donors.

Over the past few years Ramsey has consulted several major Christian broadcasters including Salem Media Group, the University of Northwestern's KTIS-FM and EMF. It is not known what, if any, role Ramsey had in EMF’s decision to change the programming on Air1.

Christian media work is personally important to Ramsey. He and his wife are active Evangelicals in San Diego.


  1. It is not just the yuppies or the overall Baby Boomers, but its also the Gen Xers that push this on the audience. They took Contemporary Worship to the next level. Chris Tomlin and Matt Redman are GenXers themselves.

    Certain millennials are actually not fans of Contemporary Worship.

    Meet Jonathan Aigner; raised a Southern Baptist and home-schooled. Turned historial classical Church Musician and currently a musician head in a Presbyterian Church (USA) in Houston, TX. Some of his ideal are quite center left as well. But on Church Worship he nails it. The Air1's of the world would disagree.

    Oh and Jonathan did actual encounter Chris Tomlin at a church camp long before Tomlin achieved greater fame as a worship leader/CCM artist. Tomlin was a camp musician and/or counselor

    Again another great piece here at Spark. Christian Music radio is not the sandbox that it used to be. It was not as experimental as mainstream public radio, but it truly has tightened up for the CCM business is now an industry rather than a movement. Yes Ken, you can be a movement and a business.

    Air1's change in music proves to me that either they don't care about reaching a younger audience and want the money demos or that audience is tired of their parents music, just as Johnny is. If you are on FB, I have written a piece about why I don't care for CCM anymore.

    If you not on FB you can email me and I will send you the piece directly if you like Ken. I think you might still have my email address.

  2. I always thought klove was worship and air1 more edgy. Why not add an alternative Christian music channel as well. Maybe not as far reaching as RadioU but in that direction