Scott Fybush |
We
hope you had the opportunity to read Scott Fybush’s op-ed in the June 4 edition
of the Boston Globe [link] about WBUR
and WGBH reimagining public radio. Fybush is a knowledgeable radio writer
because of the years he has spent as a broadcast consult and as editor of the trade
publication NorthEast Radio Watch
[link].
We
recommend Fybush’s Globe article
because it provides an excellent summary of two great stations and what may lie
ahead for both. The big news is that WBUR and WGBH are in the process of hiring
new leaders.
Charlie Kravetz |
Charlie
Kravetz left WBUR last March and Phil Redo will soon be retiring from WGBH.
Over the past few years both Kravetz and Redo have had incredible success
building audience, generating new revenue and sharpening their station’s brand.
Fybush
highlights many of the changes we have also written about recently including:
Phil Redo |
•
Since WGBH went head-to-head with WBUR with a NPR News/Talk format, the
audience for both stations has grown exponentially.
When the audiences of the
two stations are combined, Boston has one of the nation’s largest NPR News/Talk
audiences.
•
Fybush describes how both stations have differences with similar program
schedules. WBUR is focused on national
coverage, particularly with their syndicated programs Here & Now and On Point.
WGBH is all about local, local, local. WGBH also puts an emphasis on
personalities such as morning host Joe Mathieu, a Boston hometown favorite from
many years at WBZ-AM.
•
Fybush also talks about how WBUR and WGBH have been challenging Boston radio
news leader WBZ, a task once thought to be impossible.
Unfortunately,
Fybush’s narrative hits a speed bump when he wrote:
“In the most recent
Nielsen Audio ratings, WBUR was neck-and-neck with its big commercial
competitor, WBZ, with WGBH not far behind.”
This
simply isn’t true.
Spark News looked at Nielsen Audio
PPM trends from the past four years (chart on the left) and both stations have
lost listening (“AQH”) and estimated weekly listeners (“cume”) in the past 12
to 18 months.
WGBH
has lost ground in both metrics. For instance, in the PPM ratings for April and
May 2019, WGBH’s AQH share has fallen to some of the lowest levels in the past
four years. WGBH has also lost over 135,000 estimated weekly listeners, down
30%, when comparing Mary 2019 to a high point in October 2017. Ouch!
Both
statIons were at their high points in 2017 and early 2018. Back then, they were
challenging WBZ.
Now,
In the May 2019 Nielsen PPM ratings, WBZ beats both stations significant
margins in AQH and cume.
In fact, in May
“book” WGBH is even trailing WRKO-AM, a station that airs “B-list” conservative
talk hosts.
Elsewhere
in the Boston May PPM ratings Classical WCRB and AAA WUMB were up a bit.
Alt
Rock WERS had a small decline.
GEEZER ALERT: THE WPLJ REUNION PARTY
WPLJ PD & Morning Host Scott Shannon |
This
story is for a limited audience. If even
the thought of listening to a bunch of Boss
Jocks reviving memories of their younger days turns you off, then please
move on.
But,
if you ever worked in Top 40 and/or “big tent” AOR radio, or listened to WPLJ, you
will get a chuckle watching a YouTube video of the WPLJ Reunion Party in late May just before the ‘PLJ vanished from
the airwaves.
Commercial
radio archivist Art Vuolo, a/k/a Radio’s
Best Friend, produced the video. As you probably know, the legendary ‘PLJ
was sold to Educational Media Foundation (EMF) and became K-Love repeater as of May 31.
A
crowd of several hundred people with ties to WPLJ gathered at NYC’s Cutting
Room to relive their glory days. We had forgotten that ‘PLJ had so many formats
in its 30+ years, including some clinkers.
In
our opinion WPLJ had two greats eras: The 1970s progressive rock years with
personalities such as Tony Pigg and Carol Miller; and, the Rock 40 years of the
late 1980s and 1990s with Scott Shannon.
So,
polish your mood rings, put another load in the bong and bring in the “plaster
casters” while you enjoy the party:
I don't recall the specific details, but I've seen the more detailed private numbers for the Boston market and in several important dayparts, both WBUR and WGBH...
ReplyDeleteA: Are a lot more competitive with each other, although I'll come back to this.
B: Are more competitive with WBZ 1030AM.
The interesting thing about WBUR v WGBH is that, generally speaking, WBUR still does a lot better in morning & afternoon drive, whereas WGBH is killing it during the middays. The obvious analysis (possibly a bit too obvious) is that it's due to WGBH's local midday show "Boston Public Radio" and WBUR's extensive local reporting/segments during ME & ATC.
FWIW, the numbers I saw were from about seven or eight months ago, so they predated this most recent drop in the 6+ numbers. I'm not sure what to make of that.